- This topic has 12 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 11 months ago by
Intellectus.
-
AuthorPosts
-
17/05/2017 at 11:26 #17964
(kFoyauextlH thought you might appreciate this thread as well so i’ve copied and pasted it here)
I have created this thread as an exercise in exploring the deeper meanings behind concepts.
How would you go about selling your soul?
This thread is not about why you would or would not do such a thing (I know many of you would not do such a thing and think its stupid etc) that is entirely not the point.
For this exercise you will need to go into detail on 2 main parts.
1. The soul – what is it? each person here will have a differing idea of what the soul is, so go into as much detail as you can on your idea of what a soul is.
(this thread is also not about arguing over whos version of the soul is right or wrong, that does not matter and is not the point. if you have questions for somebody else, when you reply to them follow the rules laid out in their description of what a soul is, you can ask them to clarify these rules etc but dont come at them from your soul-idea because you are asking them questions about their soul-idea)
2. The sell – after you have explained in detail your idea and concept behind what a soul is describe in as best detail you can how you would go about selling it/ transferring it to somebody else etc.
I want to stress this is not about selling a novelty item such as a peice of paper stating “you own my soul” but the actual act and method of transferring your idea of the whole “Soul” as you describe above.
Not transferring the concept of the soul.
Not transferring the idea of the soul.
But the actual soul-object itself as described above.As a very simple example.
1. Soul – an apple, a tasty fruit to some varying from greens and reds comes from a tree, can fit in most hands.
2. The sell – a customer comes up to you asking to purchase a soul, you pick the soul up physically hand it to them and take some local currency in exchange, the soul is now theirs they are free to do with it what they wish. Throw it, eat it etc.
(The above is a very simple example, i will be slightly surprised if something similar comes up.)
I look forward to seeing what you can come up with.
17/05/2017 at 12:15 #19456The soul is part of the machine that knows what the machine is for. The soul may object to the machine and in that way it make itself known. The soul may of been constructesd by the machine, like a cell, replicated. It may have an outdated program ? It might be like an essence, constructed by the first layers of experience and much harder to see to get back to through all the layers, I suppose like the inner core of an onion.
As to selling the soul, it is not known who the buyer would be. The buyer would have to be outside of the machine. Maybe it would be more like a career change within the same organisation, the soul was working in the advertising department and then was transferred to the human resources department. The soul changed it’s outer layers and it’s surroundings.17/05/2017 at 16:17 #19433I think ‘a’ soul , or ‘your’ soul, ‘my’ soul is misleading for defining what soul is. As we are talking about some kind of essence, it is therefore relational and subject to dependent origination.
What is not, is something we have no possession of, it is something that appears as part of a configuration. Soul would not emerge if there were no other relations and so it is something exercised and is expressed as a value in relations.
As it is relational, ‘selling’ is already somewhat what it is – it is a gift we exchange between self and other, it is given and taken by definition as a configuration in relations. So our concept of soul is an abstraction based on value, yet the ‘thing’ in itself is no where to be found.
17/05/2017 at 23:29 #19434Beautiful! Please keep going all of you! I really enjoy this subject and wrote about it or asked about it as FreedomStands on LunaticOutpost and tried to lead conversations there on Wizard Forums at times but also wrote some emails regarding it on accounts I can’t access right now which thoroughly discuss the issue since I was being asked by people how they might go about doing this which I felt required elucidation on the elements involved. Please keep going on the topic in detail! I would also like to see some experimental thinking and pushing and grasping if possible.
18/05/2017 at 00:18 #19439How can you sell what you do not own? *mischievous grin*
How do I know I am in full possession of my soul/self? If someone does something and I get upset, now being occupied by anger/judgement, have I lost possession of myself?
In many spiritual traditions the soul is likened to a house or garden with good or bad occupants, and good or bad plants. We reap what we sow/water, and we are occupied by the influences we invite into ourselves.
“I’m not a passenger, I am the ride.” Chris Smithers
18/05/2017 at 08:21 #19454I think we can easily make the mistake of thinking there is this thing called ‘me’ in our heads and body, but there is a very tentative reasoning that revolves around ‘I’ and the truth is non-dual. As David Hume put it:
For my part, when I enter most intimately into what I call myself, I always stumble on some particular perception or other, of heat or cold, light or shade, love or hatred, pain or pleasure. I never can catch myself at any time without a perception, and never can observe any thing but the perception…. If any one, upon serious and unprejudic’d reflection thinks he has a different notion of himself, I must confess I can reason no longer with him. All I can allow him is, that he may be in the right as well as I, and that we are essentially different in this particular. He may, perhaps, perceive something simple and continu’d, which he calls himself; tho’ I am certain there is no such principle in me.
18/05/2017 at 08:48 #19464If there was only perception and no retention of it as memory, how would you ever know you had perceived anything? There is reflection upon the memory and contrast with current conditions or else no change would be perceived at all.
The “soul” at this simplest consideration is a container of information that accumulates over time with certain internal reflective/divisor membranes that allow the superposition of information across times.
[hr]
I perceive a central locus of awareness from which I look out through all the senses in all directions. It is less a point like “I” and more a bi-directional aperture.I percieve a limit to my me-ness from which I reflect inwards on all that I’ve collected from the world an all that composes my mask like persona.
I feel as a field in static repose, neither here nor there but throughout as a witness to the comings and goings of perception.
I exist as a condensation of universal process, I have been before, I will be again.
I am as I shall be.
🙂
18/05/2017 at 10:05 #19455If we are a condensation of a universal process, how can we say there is a center, or that soul/mind/spirit is centripetal? Is it not centrifugal?
Let me put it another way – there is already an amalgamation of process occuring before we even speak, we embody the world around us and finally we declare our separateness when we say ‘I’, but we have been built from the outside in the image of otherness, we are latecomers to what we call ‘now’, what appears to be a coherent, static and deliberate state of self on our part, is only a congealed process that is in flux, it only has the appearance of being solid.
‘I’ is always in flux. ‘I’ has been defined in part by the Other and so I don’t believe it to be true that ‘I’ is something that belongs to me only.
Is the breath in your body yours?
In regards to Hume, he’s pointing out how he can’t find the I empirically and so the function of ‘I’ is always pressuposed and can’t be known.
08/06/2017 at 06:01 #19440I will sell mine for a cringy uncomfortable yet comforting hug in the library between bookshelves; and 100$.
08/06/2017 at 12:17 #19438
(kFoyauextlH thought you might appreciate this thread as well so i’ve copied and pasted it here)I have created this thread as an exercise in exploring the deeper meanings behind concepts.
How would you go about selling your soul?
This thread is not about why you would or would not do such a thing (I know many of you would not do such a thing and think its stupid etc) that is entirely not the point.
For this exercise you will need to go into detail on 2 main parts.
1. The soul – what is it? each person here will have a differing idea of what the soul is, so go into as much detail as you can on your idea of what a soul is.
(this thread is also not about arguing over whos version of the soul is right or wrong, that does not matter and is not the point. if you have questions for somebody else, when you reply to them follow the rules laid out in their description of what a soul is, you can ask them to clarify these rules etc but dont come at them from your soul-idea because you are asking them questions about their soul-idea)
2. The sell – after you have explained in detail your idea and concept behind what a soul is describe in as best detail you can how you would go about selling it/ transferring it to somebody else etc.
I want to stress this is not about selling a novelty item such as a peice of paper stating “you own my soul” but the actual act and method of transferring your idea of the whole “Soul” as you describe above.
Not transferring the concept of the soul.
Not transferring the idea of the soul.
But the actual soul-object itself as described above.As a very simple example.
1. Soul – an apple, a tasty fruit to some varying from greens and reds comes from a tree, can fit in most hands.
2. The sell – a customer comes up to you asking to purchase a soul, you pick the soul up physically hand it to them and take some local currency in exchange, the soul is now theirs they are free to do with it what they wish. Throw it, eat it etc.
(The above is a very simple example, i will be slightly surprised if something similar comes up.)
I look forward to seeing what you can come up with.
From elsewhere: “Ok. So.
0. I would go about selling my soul easily as follows (and the pact is mentioned in the Qur’an as well and is made during the worship practice repeatedly during the kneeling phase of the exercise.):1. The Soul does not exist in my view at all as what people tend to use the term for. When they use the term, like their misuse of the word “energy” (which means action or potention for activity), which they take as a sort of material or substance that works like a viscous liquid, they are referring to something which the term was not really used for and which they only imagine mainly. The Soul according to most people is imagined to refer to some sort of ghost matter being or copy of themselves living inside of their body, which can come out of the body and do things or leaves the body upon death. This is a sort of dualism where they consider physical matter one sort and “spirit matter” another sort, and the spirit matter is inside the physical matter and making it move and when it is gone the body is dead. They describe demons as being made of this spirit material which can also enter bodies or influence and control bodies or minds the way their spirit material does, and to dominate their ghosts or supress them while the demon is filling the space or hijacking the person. This is all superstitious silliness m which people seem to describe and imagine without saying as much directly or formulating their ideas clearly or proving it. There is no evidence of “spirit matter” or any such dynamics existing. A demon need not be what they say and imagine, and had they ever encountered a real “spirit creature” they would still probably say foolish things like “alternate dimension, spirit energy, negative, positive”. There are carbon based lifeforms and plasma based life forms. Modern scientists and humans have published very little recently on plasma based life forms because most likely find it hard to find and capture and study them, plus doing so might be terrible indeed. Both carbon based life forms and plasma based life forms are living in this world, are visible, can be photographed, they are made of matter, real things, real material, they are not “energy (action) substance” they look most often like a fine mist when dispersing their membrane. Most people have probably had run ins with them or close encounters but since they are expecting girls in white dresses and other silly stuff, they don’t notice if a plasma based creature is right by them or flies right by. They are not invisible to anyone, you don’t need the ability to lie “The Second Sight” to see them. They can be recorded, filmed with cameras and infared heat vision and whatever, plainly there. They are not “magical” how people tend to use the term to mean “able to do things without the proper steps involved” or immortal but because people don’t know what is going on they can appear magical if people get lost in deluded thinking which they seem perpetually ready to do.
There is no Soul the way people use it. The term usually translated as soul in the Bible meant the person, generally even referring to the body of a person. Nefesh. You don’t exist unless you are present in matter in some form, or rather, you don’t exist unless you are experiencing and when you are experiencing information, that is all you are, a screen of unique experience (so for the even more advanced understanding, you have no access to anything except information, which is all you know or experience in a moment). There are other concepts used for the word soul, meaning the animation a person is experiencing, generally in other things, which the word spiritus originallt meant, animation, movement. The word spirit is used often to refer to the “energy substance” mentioned before, but has also been used to refer to overall themes which seem to organize things in a certain way, so like “The Spirit of War” being over a warlike people or Neo-Nazi rally or something. It is also used for an idea of extending outward and into thing as reflective of certain qualities thought to be associated with a thing or a person “I see in this letter their spirit, they are so kind” meaning that the material witnessed seems to be organized in such a way that it reflects their tendency or habits or typical activity.
There is no such thing as “dead people who are talking” because if anyone or anything is truly doing anything, they are not dead but active and animated and present. So this is just a confusion regarding proper usage of the word dead. What is truly dead can not do anything. For the advanced thinker, we are all dead, and the Power alone is Alive, the Living, or Animator.
Now the Soul as used in literature, tends to secretly refer to or make reference to the notion of “the life activities and personality of a person, their whole life” which culminates in their death and begins at their quickening in the womb. Your whole life. This is then what seems to be “called to account, judged, weighed, measured” metaphorically as a more complete estimation of the person as a category of reference or file. Then the person is categorized based on that complete file or record of their conduct or form as it was said to be from their beginning to their end on Earth, and they are sorted into a new habitation based on where the file is deemed suitable or appropriate. Thus, in narratives about soul sales, we see that often at the end the person is dead and then the soul, which is their whole record and being, is taken to a torturous domain and a new life. This means the term was being used in a way that “your soul becomes ugly if it is full of bad deeds” meaning your record reflects your conduct. Think of Dorian Gray’s Painting. The Painting was supposed to depict the true image or state of his soul or current or complete up to date record as it progressed, even though one could not see it on his body. This idea was more present seeming in a recent film version as well which included a pact scene.
To sell your soul could thus be taken as terminology for working in devotion, giving one’s whole life to a cause. This “loan” and statements like these are recorded in the Qur’an. One gives their whole life’s activities towards the Cause of Allah, who the medieval people considered Light Bearer (Lucifer).
When you sell your soul, you may be taken to account later or immediately begin work as an agent in the manner of Mephistopheles, who was said to have sold his soul and was now a bodily slave, servant, and agent in the cause of the Devil (who the medieval people considered Odin, Mercury, Allah, whose active form they called Mahound for Muhammed and later took to using the word Baphomet from the Old French Occitan for Muhammed).
People who sell their soul for money are thus those who wholly dedicate their life’s activities and efforts to the cause of seeking Mammon (meaning Wealth).
How the real activity would occur is that the person then becomes increasingly entangled with matters dealing with Mammon, and when they die, the complete set of all that are said to be their activities or life’s work, will reflect that they sought wealth and what they did. In the meantime though, the “product” had been their body and bodily activities and acts associated with them which shaped the picture or portrait of their character or life.”
17/06/2017 at 17:33 #19465
(kFoyauextlH thought you might appreciate this thread as well so i’ve copied and pasted it here)I have created this thread as an exercise in exploring the deeper meanings behind concepts.
How would you go about selling your soul?
This thread is not about why you would or would not do such a thing (I know many of you would not do such a thing and think its stupid etc) that is entirely not the point.
For this exercise you will need to go into detail on 2 main parts.
1. The soul – what is it? each person here will have a differing idea of what the soul is, so go into as much detail as you can on your idea of what a soul is.
(this thread is also not about arguing over whos version of the soul is right or wrong, that does not matter and is not the point. if you have questions for somebody else, when you reply to them follow the rules laid out in their description of what a soul is, you can ask them to clarify these rules etc but dont come at them from your soul-idea because you are asking them questions about their soul-idea)
2. The sell – after you have explained in detail your idea and concept behind what a soul is describe in as best detail you can how you would go about selling it/ transferring it to somebody else etc.
I want to stress this is not about selling a novelty item such as a peice of paper stating “you own my soul” but the actual act and method of transferring your idea of the whole “Soul” as you describe above.
Not transferring the concept of the soul.
Not transferring the idea of the soul.
But the actual soul-object itself as described above.As a very simple example.
1. Soul – an apple, a tasty fruit to some varying from greens and reds comes from a tree, can fit in most hands.
2. The sell – a customer comes up to you asking to purchase a soul, you pick the soul up physically hand it to them and take some local currency in exchange, the soul is now theirs they are free to do with it what they wish. Throw it, eat it etc.
(The above is a very simple example, i will be slightly surprised if something similar comes up.)
I look forward to seeing what you can come up with.
The soul is the source or meaning of one’s purpose in life. Everything in nature has a purpose and the soul is just another word created from the Brain. I mentioned the gut brain in another post and I believe this is where the soul is. This is why some people believe in “soul food” because it is hunger that you must feed in order to subside it. But how does one’s soul “eat”? I can go about this a couple of ways but soul is closely related to the spiritual realm so I’ll start there. I personally believe that religion is just a perspective of some very intelligence people who created a notion of control by providing stories to the masses. We seek power, and there are a few ways to get it, but the best way is through the soul. So the stories of religion base the stories on the soul, therefore everything that comes from religion has to do with someone’s soul. This is actually correct as the soul is actually the source. But the name “source” is just my interpretation of the soul and just another perspective in the World. I believe my notions are absolute in their meanings but can’t really be comprehended by another because the language to express what I truly feel is not created yet. So if the language isn’t created to express myself, how can people take me serious when I talk about what my holograms are. But to get back on track….the soul is the source or the beginning of creation.
To sell my soul is to be completely honest in what it is. However, I wouldn’t want my soul to be in anyone but me. However, he one really wanted it…I would sell it for nothing. because i believe if the person “wore” my soul, he/she would go mad. its my soul…its original and therefore wouldn’t like it if I gave it away. So in a sense its alive, like another separate being inside me. Except its absolute and divine and selfish, everything that I am not but I accepted it so in return, it accepted me. And I became whole. Which is another way of saying that I actually found my source and would love for someone to “try it on” at least. In other words, tell me what you think?
18/06/2017 at 08:45 #19453
I mentioned the gut brain in another post and I believe this is where the soul is.
Sounds a lot like Gilles Deleuze take on Spinoza and nutrition, which I mentioned in another thread: https://ontic-philosophy.com/Thread-Beginners-Spinoza-Nourished-or-poisoned-essences
I personally believe that religion is just a perspective of some very intelligence people who created a notion of control by providing stories to the masses.
Marx said this.
I believe my notions are absolute in their meanings but can’t really be comprehended by another because the language to express what I truly feel is not created yet.I can understand this, you have a gut feeling about what’s going on and then you try to express it, but language fails you. In all seriousness, why is that you have no problem with expressing your feelings, or having the pursuit of it and others don’t? In other threads you always talk about ‘logic before feelings’ but this post here tells a totally different story.
If you can ever drop your notions of me as an SJW, we could do a lot of work here that would be of value to all of us.
So if the language isn’t created to express myself, how can people take me serious when I talk about what my holograms are. But to get back on track….the soul is the source or the beginning of creation.
We all have to ‘come to terms’.
To sell my soul is to be completely honest in what it is. However, I wouldn’t want my soul to be in anyone but me. However, he one really wanted it…I would sell it for nothing. because i believe if the person “wore” my soul, he/she would go mad. its my soul…its original and therefore wouldn’t like it if I gave it away. So in a sense its alive, like another separate being inside me.Cartesian Dualism and Vitalism. Also, a sale without price is a gift.
Except its absolute and divine and selfish, everything that I am not but I accepted it so in return, it accepted me. And I became whole. Which is another way of saying that I actually found my source and would love for someone to “try it on” at least. In other words, tell me what you think?I think you perceive your soul as an unobtainable ideal that you try to fulfill and always fail at.
18/06/2017 at 15:38 #19476
I mentioned the gut brain in another post and I believe this is where the soul is.
Sounds a lot like Gilles Deleuze take on Spinoza and nutrition, which I mentioned in another thread: https://ontic-philosophy.com/Thread-Beginners-Spinoza-Nourished-or-poisoned-essences
I personally believe that religion is just a perspective of some very intelligence people who created a notion of control by providing stories to the masses.
Marx said this.
I believe my notions are absolute in their meanings but can’t really be comprehended by another because the language to express what I truly feel is not created yet.I can understand this, you have a gut feeling about what’s going on and then you try to express it, but language fails you. In all seriousness, why is that you have no problem with expressing your feelings, or having the pursuit of it and others don’t? In other threads you always talk about ‘logic before feelings’ but this post here tells a totally different story.
If you can ever drop your notions of me as an SJW, we could do a lot of work here that would be of value to all of us.
So if the language isn’t created to express myself, how can people take me serious when I talk about what my holograms are. But to get back on track….the soul is the source or the beginning of creation.
We all have to ‘come to terms’.
To sell my soul is to be completely honest in what it is. However, I wouldn’t want my soul to be in anyone but me. However, he one really wanted it…I would sell it for nothing. because i believe if the person “wore” my soul, he/she would go mad. its my soul…its original and therefore wouldn’t like it if I gave it away. So in a sense its alive, like another separate being inside me.Cartesian Dualism and Vitalism. Also, a sale without price is a gift.
Except its absolute and divine and selfish, everything that I am not but I accepted it so in return, it accepted me. And I became whole. Which is another way of saying that I actually found my source and would love for someone to “try it on” at least. In other words, tell me what you think?I think you perceive your soul as an unobtainable ideal that you try to fulfill and always fail at.
I love your insights as it created more and more ideas that answered my own questions about life and my pursuit of finding “it”. I have no problem saying what I feel as I speak from the “gut brain” and not my actual brain most of the time. Its like something is controlling my hands as I type but I dont really care what I put down…as I already have the answers I seek. I take everything that I have ever heard, saw, felt, tasted, smelled and put it under one big microscope where my “gut brain” is doing the research and my brain is just managing the speed at which I can go. Like the “gut brain” is the navigation, but the brain is driving. This is why I love to learn…I’m gaining more and more perspectives but can take my time because I am unknown. I am not known to anyone and I love the feeling when someone meets me because I am just a reflection of their inner most being. In other words, I act like a mirror, or atleast try to do as someone who is talking to themselves always agrees with them. Thats just me, Mr. understanding which is Intellectus in Latin. The more I reveal myself to this World, the more I feel alone. As I listen to the music that is created by others, I can’t help but feel the emotions that they felt when they wrote it. It sometimes makes me cry, or get mad, or even just mellow. I constantly smoke the best THC, which is what happen to me to open my mind up to “it.”
My search for the “it” is never complete but it is complete when I say it is. This is why I can keep learning but don’t really enjoy it at times. Being here has taught me many things as I write my story. But my story is just that. A way to express myself to show others “the way” which is my “it” but again. Unobtainable, but that will never stop me from failing. As failing is just learning from the mistakes to me and I love learning….and failing…and learning…and so on and so forth. Like the primordial spiral.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.